A security boss who ran seven companies under four different identities has been found guilty of defrauding security operatives who worked for him. John Gaines, 72, of Leamington Spa, was found guilty of 22 charges of fraud at Warwick Crown Court on Monday 30 September.
Gaines employed Security Industry Authority (SIA) licensed security officers at a number of locations, including construction sites belonging to Heathrow Airport and Tesco. In many cases, Gaines either failed to pay them in full or didn’t pay them at all.
Gaines was also found guilty of claiming to be “SIA approved”, despite not being a member of the SIA Approved Contractor Scheme. Sentencing has been deferred to 14 November pending the production of a pre-sentencing report. Gaines has been remanded into custody in the meantime.
Nathan Salmon of the SIA’s criminal investigations team said: “I’m grateful to the Jury for returning guilty verdicts on all 22 counts in this case. In part, private security regulation was introduced to address “cowboy” operators, and I can think of no better word to describe Gaines’ actions. Through various aliases and phantom businesses, Gaines set out to employ security operatives, withholding their pay while profiting from his contracts. He employed new staff to replace those who left, continuing his fraudulent behaviour many times over. He sought to conceal his identity, hid behind wild excuses and was threatening towards some employees who were merely seeking payment for the work they did for him.”
Salmon added: “The SIA recognised the harm Gaines was causing to regulated individuals within our industry and I’m grateful to the 21 employee victims who bravely came forward to secure this conviction.”
Complaints to Action Fraud
The case was brought to the SIA’s attention following a series of complaints to the police and Action Fraud. These complaints related to companies that were under suspicion of failing to pay security operatives. Analysis had shown that several of the companies in question shared e-mail addresses and phone numbers. This information was passed to the SIA by the Government Agency Intelligence Network (GAIN).
The SIA conducted a lengthy and complex UK-wide investigation into a number of contracts running from 2012 to early 2016. Those contracts had all been secured by one individual, namely John Wear Gaines, using various pseudonyms and different company names.
In conjunction with Warwickshire Police, the SIA arrested Gaines in October 2017 and seized material linking him not only to the businesses in question, but also to several alternative identities. This material included hundreds of business cards and flyers at Gaines’ house in the names of Geoff Caines, Robert Fox and David Ward. The “David Ward” cards contained the claim to be “SIA approved”.
Most of the businesses Gaines ran were sole trading entities, run virtually from his home. Only one, namely Crown/Accord Nationwide Security, was registered at Companies House. The company director was listed as “Jeff Cains”, another alias of John Gaines.
Gaines told the court that the workers whom he failed to pay were either “asleep on the job” or had failed to provide proper documentation. However, the court heard from a variety of witnesses who claimed that he refused to supply written contacts, ignored requests for payment and left threatening phone messages for those whom he defrauded.